Homeowners in Ohio face tough choices when it’s time to replace a roof. We get it — the quote arrives, and suddenly you’re weighing durability, cost, and future headaches all at once. Asphalt shingles have been the standard for years, but metal roofing has become a proven upgrade with long-term benefits. At the end of the day, most people just want a roof that protects their home and budget — both today and decades from now.
Working as the #1 Rated Roofing Company in Ohio, we’ve helped countless homeowners compare the upfront price vs. long-term value of each material. And the truth? The answer to Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles? is more layered than it seems.
Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles?
(short H2)
Asphalt shingles almost always appear cheaper at the start. Materials cost less, installation is faster, and crews are familiar with the product. But shingle roofs usually last 18–25 years, meaning most homeowners will replace them more than once. Over a lifetime of ownership, those costs add up quickly.
Metal roofs cost more upfront, often 2–3 times the price of a basic shingle roof. But metal typically lasts 40–70 years, resists Ohio weather better, and requires fewer repairs. When we break down the math with clients, total long-term cost often favors metal, especially for people who plan to stay in their homes.
Shingles: The Lower Initial Cost Option
Shingles come in a wide range of styles and price points. They’re ideal if you’re working with a smaller budget or plan to sell your home within a decade. Repairs are simple, replacements are predictable, and contractors are widely available.
However, damage from wind, hail, and UV rays can shorten lifespan. Even architectural shingles can fail earlier if ventilation or installation isn’t perfect. When homeowners ask Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles? we always explain that lower cost today doesn’t always mean lower cost later.
Metal Roofing: Higher Price, Greater Durability
Metal roofs demand a larger initial investment, but that price comes with exceptional longevity. They hold up to snow loads, heavy rain, and dramatic freeze-thaw cycles that Ohio experiences. Many come with 40–50 year warranties, which is a major reassurance for long-term homeowners.
Metal also reflects more sunlight, which reduces cooling costs in the summer.
That’s one more way a premium Roof Installation ends up saving money over time.
Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles? Breaking down hidden costs
Little details can create big cost differences over the life of a roof: maintenance, storm repairs, ventilation corrections, and even insurance discounts. Metal roofs rarely suffer from granular loss, cracking, or missing pieces after storms, while shingles often need patchwork.
If you need multiple repairs each year, that low-cost installation becomes an ongoing expense. As the #1 Rated Roofing Company in Ohio, we’ve helped homeowners uncover thousands in savings by preventing those recurring issues with a well-built metal system.
Curb Appeal and Resale Value
A roof changes the entire look of a home. Metal roofing offers modern style and sharp profiles that can elevate a property instantly. Buyers see a metal roof as a major long-term asset — meaning sellers may recover more of the investment.
Shingles still offer beautiful aesthetic options too, especially architectural shingles that mimic more premium materials. A well-planned Roof Installation with the right color and profile can boost confidence and buying interest no matter which path you choose.
Weather Resistance: Designed for Ohio Conditions
Ohio homes battle all four seasons — sometimes in the same week. Asphalt shingles can become brittle in cold snaps or soften in extreme heat. High winds and hail storms are common causes of early failure.
Metal roofing provides stronger defense against impacts, ice, and severe storms. It sheds water efficiently and rarely needs emergency repairs. Homeowners who want fewer insurance claims often choose metal for that peace of mind.
Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles? Final Considerations Before You Decide
The short answer:
✔ Shingles are cheaper upfront.
✔ Metal is cheaper long-term for many homeowners.
If you’re planning to move soon or need to manage immediate expenses, shingles remain a smart and reliable choice. But if this is your “forever home,” metal delivers superior value over decades.
Budget, timing, and personal priorities all matter. That’s why we sit down with homeowners and map out the numbers in writing — lifespan, materials, warranties, and estimated repairs. When everything is on the table, the best decision becomes much clearer.
The #1 Rated Roofing Company in Ohio — Here to Help
Choosing a roof isn’t just about covering a house. It’s about protecting your biggest investment with a solution that fits your lifestyle and future plans. We specialize in guiding homeowners through the decision-making process — with transparency and zero pressure.
If you’re wondering Is it cheaper to put a metal roof or shingles?, we’ll help you compare the true costs so you feel confident from day one. We handle everything from inspection to Roof Installation to ensure a smooth, stress-free experience.
A durable roof is one of the wisest investments you can make in your home. No matter which material you choose, we’re here to help you get it right.